REVIEWS

Digging Deeper: A Canadian Reporter’s Research Guide

By Robert Cribb, Dean Jobb, David McKie, Fred Vallance-Jones
Oxford University Press, 2006
259 pages
http://www.oup.com/ca/isbn/0-19-542127-2
http://www.carincanada.ca/DiggingDeeper.htm

Review by Kendyl Salcito, June 2006

Digging Deeper: A Canadian Reporter’s Research Guide was co-written by four award-winning journalists who also teach journalism. Between reporting and teaching, clearly they grasped how insufficient American investigative reporting guides are for students north of the 49th Parallel. Digging Deeper is the first and only investigative reporting guide written with Canadian systems, policies and infrastructure in mind. That alone should guarantee its success across the country, but it’s not just the only Canadian investigative guide -- it’s also a very good one.

Authors Cribb, Jobb, McKie and Vallance-Jones touch on all the bases for good reporting in the first half of the text, then they shift their focus in the second half to the very specific tools and techniques that will help journalists break through bureaucratic barriers and organizational holdups.

The general information -- including a review of different primary and secondary sources and a summary of “twelve keys,” like tenacity, skepticism, and curiosity, to give a journalist the mentality for success -- resembled many how-to journalism texts that preceded Digging Deeper. While law, interviewing techniques and information gathering are necessary elements to any report (and hence any reporting text), the information is sometimes too general to be valuable and too cursory to be informative. ‘Public records,’ for example, occupies almost 30 pages, but it needs triple that space to actually address the dozens of types of records mentioned and URLs listed. Young B.C. journalists scrolling through web address lists might be disappointed to learn that BC Online, listed as a great resource for land titles, is a pricey, subscription-only tool. And reporters looking for in-depth information about labour disputes will find that Ontario’s Ministry of Labour offers frequent online updates, whereas B.C.’s Labour Ministry only posts about one report a year. Digging Deeper’s authors all live and work east of the Canadian Rockies, and their oversight of B.C.-oriented issues is notable.

The media law section also suffers from a wealth of information condensed into a recap. The reader is introduced to the justice system, not shown how to approach it. The chapter’s concluding anecdote is a microcosm of the chapter itself, rehashing a 1992 Montreal Gazette story on judicial scandal without mentioning how the investigation was accomplished.

A research guide can only be so long, though, and elaborating on courts and records could easily have spun the compact 260-page book into a 1000-page tome.

Digging Deeper really shines when it moves away from the basics of good reporting and hones in on specific techniques. The text’s coverage of Freedom of Information, Computer-Assisted Reporting, and financial reporting make it truly invaluable.

Aptly, the authors note that journalists shy away from numbers. Then, they take the reader step by step through sample finance reports, excel spreadsheets and database managers, highlighting the most vital tools and info that each provides. The text offers tips, including what numbers should catch a journalist’s eye on a 10-K and what steps are necessary to sort spreadsheet data into chronological order.

The FOI section provides clear and encompassing guidance for facing reticent Information Officers who use fees and delays to waylay an information request. Digging Deeper’s links to sites like CAIRS -- for past Access to Information requests -- and provincial and federal ATI sites also make the FOI process more accessible to starting journalists.

Probably the most useful section of the book begins after the text ends. Appendices A, B, and C are guides to spreadsheets, databases and financial information, respectively. With bullet points, diagrams, and web links, book lays plain all the basics of three extremely valuable, rarely used tools that new journalists should embrace. The explanations are so methodical that following them is astoundingly easy.

A guide to Canadian investigative reporting and researching has been much-needed for years now, and Digging Deeper fills the void extremely well.

 



Robert Cribb
is an award-winning investigative reporter at the Toronto Star. He teaches investigative journalism at Ryerson University.

Dean Jobb, a former reporter, editor, and columnist with the Halifax Herald, deaches investigative reporting and editing at the University of King’s College School of Journalism in Halifax.

David McKie is an award-winning journalist with CBC News Investigative Unit. He is a specialist in computer-assisted reporting and teaches investigative journalism at Carleton University’s School of Journalism

Fred Vallance-Jones, one of the country’s foremost expoerts on CAR and an award-winning special reports writer with The Hamilton Spectator, teaches at the Ryerson School of Journalism


Previous reviews
Gender, Conflict & Journalism
By Fiona Lloyd and Ross Howard
Review by Carolynne Burkholder, April 2006

Media Law for Canadian Journalists
By Dean Jobb
Review by Lisa Taylor, February 2006

Film “Capote ”Raises Disturbing Ethical Questions
By Peter Klein, January 2006

Review of two books by Kendyl Salcito
: Morals and the Media (Nick Russell, UBC Press) and Black, White and Grey: Ethics in South African Journalism (Franz Kruger, Cape Town)

 


  Copyright © 2009 School of Journalism & Mass Communication, University of Wisconsin-Madison. All rights reserved. Site by www.kitsmedia.ca